The 1958 College Football Playoff would have had included the #1 LSU Tigers (10-0-0), #2 Iowa Hawkeyes (7-1-1), #3 Army Cadets (8-0-1), and #4 Auburn Tigers (9-0-1).
Games are simulated in a custom text sim, and results recreated in NCAA Football 11.
Box Scores
Sugar Bowl
Auburn 16, Louisiana State 13
Louisiana State
Warren Rabb: 10/20, 139 Yds, TD, Int
Billy Cannon: 22 Car, 97 Yds, TD
Johnny Robinson: 3 Rec, 50 Yds, TD
Auburn
Lloyd Nix: 11/22, 146 Yds, TD, 2 Int
Ed Dyas: 16 Car, 52 Yds, TD
Geral Wilson: 3 Rec, 38 Yds, TD
Orange Bowl
Army 24, Iowa 14
Iowa
Randy Duncan: 10/24, 136 Yds, TD, 3 Int
Ray Jauch: 16 Car, 89 Yds, TD
Don Norton: 2 Rec, 34 Yds, TD
Army
Joe Caldwell: 8/21, 150 Yds, 2 TD, Int
Bob Anderson: 21 Car, 98 Yds, TD
Pete Dawkins: 2 Rec, 58 Yds, TD
Cotton Bowl (National Championship)
Army 24, Auburn 17
Army
Joe Caldwell: 8/19, 153 Yds, TD, Int
Bob Anderson: 19 Car, 90 Yds, TD
Pete Dawkins: 2 Rec, 48 Yds, TD
Auburn
Lloyd Nix: 9/18, 118, TD, Int
Ed Dyas: 12 Car, 53 Yds, TD
Leo Sexton: 2 Rec, 27 Yds, TD