The 1958 College Football Playoff would have had included the #1 Georgia Bulldogs (11-0-0), #2 Florida State Seminoles (10-1-0), #3 Pittsburgh Panthers (10-1-0), and #4 Oklahoma Sooners (9-2-0).
Games are simulated in a custom text sim, and results recreated in NCAA Football 11.
Box Scores
Cotton Bowl
#1 Georgia 17, #4 Oklahoma 14
Georgia
Buck Belue: 7/13, 95 Yds, TD, Int
Herschel Walker: 27 Car, 142 Yds, TD
Lindsay Scott: 2 Rec, 33 Yds, TD
Oklahoma
J.C. Watts: 2/8, 56 Yds, Int
J.C. Watts: 21 Car, 100 Yds, TD
Bobby Grayson: 1 Rec, 30 Yds
Sugar Bowl
#3 Pittsburgh 24, #2 Florida State 20
Florida State
Rick Stockstill: 9/20, 108 Yds, TD, Int
Sam Platt: 22 Car, 99 Yds, TD
Hardis Johnson: 2 Rec, 26 Yds, TD
Pittsburgh
Dan Marino: 12/32, 183 Yds, TD, 2 Int
Randy McMillan: 18 Car, 84 Yds, TD
Dwight Collins: 2 Rec, 44 Yds, TD
Fiesta Bowl (National Championship)
#3 Pittsburgh 20, #1 Georgia 17
Georgia
Buck Belue: 7/15, 110 Yds, TD, Int
Herschel Walker: 32 Car, 180 Yds, TD
Amp Arnold: 2 Rec, 35 Yds, TD
Pittsburgh
Dan Marino: 21/39, 309 Yds, TD, 2 Int
Randy McMillan: 19 Car, 77 Yds, TD
Benjie Pryor: 5 Rec, 72 Yds, TD